Being an “estranged” child comes with a particularly peculiar set of emotions. Emotions that can take years, a frankly unreasonable amount of therapy, and a lot of uncomfortable self-reflection to even begin to understand.
Because there is something particularly bizarre about grieving somebody who is still alive.
Somebody you could, technically, pick up the phone and call. Somebody who is still going about their life, making memories and existing in the world, but who you can no longer speak to. Or, perhaps more accurately, somebody you know you shouldn't speak to, because you've spent so much time trying to understand why that relationship causes you more harm than good.
And yet, despite everything, there are still moments when you desperately wish you could reach for them.
I think this is one of the most difficult things to explain about family estrangement. You can know that distancing yourself from somebody was the right decision, understand exactly why you made it, and still find yourself longing for their approval, support or reassurance.
Not necessarily because you want them back in your life as they actually are, but because some part of you still wants them to be the person you needed them to be.
And that's a rather uncomfortable thing to come to terms with.
Those who haven't had to reconcile the idea that the people who are supposed to bring unconditional love, safety and security into their lives are, in fact, the very people causing them harm, can struggle to understand the situation. And I don't blame them for that. It's difficult to comprehend a reality you've never had to live with.
They will often look at you with an awkward, puzzled expression, usually after asking something perfectly innocent like, “How's your family?” You give an honest answer, they realise they've stumbled into a conversation they weren't expecting, and suddenly they're desperately trying to find something else to talk about.
It's a little like watching somebody attempt an emergency landing in the middle of a perfectly ordinary conversation.
Truthfully, I'm quite glad when this happens. It usually means that the person I'm speaking to has enjoyed a relatively happy and stable family dynamic, something I genuinely believe everyone deserves. I'm not resentful of people who have had a more positive experience of family than I have, and I don't want this article to be interpreted in that way. I'm always genuinely happy to hear people talk fondly about their childhoods, their parents and the memories they've made together.
I wouldn't wish my experience on anybody, and I certainly wouldn't want somebody else's happiness to be diminished simply because mine has looked a little different.
But I do think there's room for the other side of the conversation, too.
I want to explore why somebody might reach the point of removing parents, grandparents or other family members from their lives, how difficult that decision can be, and what happens emotionally once you've made it.
Because I don't think we talk about family estrangement openly enough. And, in particular, I don't think we talk enough about the grief that comes with it: the peculiar experience of still wanting something from somebody you've had to accept you may never receive it from.
Nobody cuts off their family for the fun of it:
I think it's important to start here, because there's a persistent assumption that children who distance themselves from their parents are being selfish, ungrateful, dramatic or unwilling to forgive.
That they've fallen out over something trivial, that they've been influenced by somebody else, or that they're holding on to a grudge when they should really just learn to move on.
There's often an underlying expectation that, whatever has happened, family should be family. That blood is somehow enough to make a relationship worth preserving, regardless of what that relationship actually looks like.
But sharing DNA with somebody doesn't automatically make them a safe person. Being somebody's parent doesn't grant them an unlimited licence to hurt you. And the fact that somebody raised you doesn't mean you owe them unrestricted access to your life forever.
For some people, estrangement follows a particularly significant event. For others, it's the culmination of years of smaller hurts, broken promises, boundary violations and disappointments that gradually chip away at whatever relationship existed in the first place.
Sometimes, it isn't even one particularly dramatic moment. It's the realisation that you've had the same conversation a hundred times, explained your feelings until you're exhausted, given somebody opportunity after opportunity to do things differently, and somehow ended up back in precisely the same position.
It's the slow understanding that you cannot make somebody acknowledge the harm they've caused, no matter how carefully you explain it. That you cannot force somebody to take accountability, offer a genuine apology or demonstrate that they're willing to change.
Eventually, you reach a point where you have to ask yourself how much more you're prepared to sacrifice in the hope that things might one day be different.
I don't think people always appreciate how difficult that decision is, especially when the relationship is with a parent. There's an enormous amount of societal expectation attached to that particular relationship.
We're taught that our parents love us unconditionally, that they'll always be there for us and that, regardless of what happens, we'll always have somewhere to turn.
When that isn't your experience, there's a lot to untangle. You're not only dealing with the relationship itself, but also trying to reconcile it with everything you've been taught that relationship is supposed to mean.
And even when you reach the conclusion that distance is necessary, that doesn't mean you stop caring.
Sometimes, it simply means you've accepted that you cannot continue putting yourself in a position where you're repeatedly hurt by the same people.
There's a difference between choosing to hurt somebody and choosing to stop allowing yourself to be hurt.
Unfortunately, from the outside, those two things can look remarkably similar.
The grief nobody quite knows what to do with:
One of the strangest things about family estrangement is that it comes with a kind of grief that doesn't fit neatly into any of the boxes we tend to associate with loss.
There is no funeral. No obituary. No socially recognised period of mourning. No moment when somebody brings you a cup of tea, puts an arm around your shoulder and tells you they're sorry for your loss.
Because, technically, there hasn't been one.
The person is still here. They're still living their life, celebrating birthdays and making memories. They might be just a phone call away. You might know exactly where they are and how to contact them.
And yet, you cannot speak to them.
Or perhaps you technically can, but you know that doing so would mean reopening wounds you've spent years trying to heal.
I find that particularly difficult to explain, because you can't simply draw a line under the relationship and decide that you no longer have any feelings about it.
You might feel completely at peace with your decision one day, genuinely grateful for the distance and the life you've managed to build without the constant stress of that relationship. Then something happens, seemingly out of nowhere, and you find yourself feeling sad about it all over again.
And you almost feel a little ridiculous for it.
After all, you made the decision. You know why you made it. You've probably spent hours discussing it in therapy, analysing it from every possible angle and questioning whether there was anything you could have done differently.
Surely, at some point, you should just be over it?
Except grief doesn't really work like that, does it?
We sometimes assume that making the right decision should automatically make us feel good about it. That if something is necessary for our wellbeing, we should eventually reach a point where we're entirely comfortable with what we've had to give up.
But you can be relieved that somebody is no longer part of your life and still be sad that they aren't.
You can recognise that a relationship was unhealthy and still feel a pang of something that resembles homesickness.
Except you're not homesick for a place.
You're homesick for a feeling. Or, perhaps more accurately, for the feeling you always hoped that place would give you.
And I think that's where estrangement becomes particularly complicated. Sometimes, you're not grieving what you had. You're grieving what you thought you would have.
The people you still want to call:
This is the part I find particularly difficult to reconcile.
Despite everything, there are still moments when you want to reach for the very people you've had to distance yourself from.
Not because you've forgotten what happened, but because life has a habit of throwing things at you when you're least prepared for them.
When something goes wrong. When you're frightened, overwhelmed or struggling to make sense of something. When you receive news you don't know how to process, or you're facing a particularly difficult decision and could really do with somebody telling you that everything is going to be okay.
And somewhere, almost instinctively, your mind goes to them.
You want to tell them what's happened. You want them to reassure you. You want them to tell you that you're doing well, that they're proud of you, that you don't have to figure everything out alone.
You want to pick up the phone without having to think about the consequences.
And then you remember.
You remember why you can't. Why you don't. Why, despite how desperately you might want that person to be there for you, you cannot rely on them to provide the support you need.
It's a particularly cruel little emotional boomerang, really. You spend so much time learning to live without somebody, building a life in which their absence is no longer a constant source of pain, only for a difficult moment to send you straight back to the realisation that they're not there.
And sometimes, what you're longing for isn't actually the person themselves.
It's what you want them to represent.
The parent who would comfort you without making you feel worse. The family member who would listen without turning the conversation back on you. The person who could put their own feelings aside for five minutes and simply be there when you needed them.
You want somebody to take care of you for a change.
I don't think there's anything particularly unreasonable about that.
The difficulty is that, when those needs haven't been met by the people you expected to meet them, the longing doesn't necessarily disappear just because you've accepted that those people are unable or unwilling to do so.
You can know that somebody isn't a reliable source of support and still want them to be.
And sometimes, I think, we confuse that longing with missing the relationship itself.
But there's a difference between wanting somebody back and wanting them to have been different.
Because the reality of the relationship is the reason you had to leave in the first place.
Mourning a relationship that never really existed:
I think this is where the grief becomes particularly difficult to untangle.
You might have some genuinely lovely memories of the people you're estranged from. There might have been moments of affection, happiness and connection. I'm not suggesting that every relationship that ends in estrangement was entirely bad, or that the good parts weren't real.
In fact, I think that's part of what makes it so difficult.
Relationships can contain moments of genuine warmth alongside patterns of behaviour that are deeply damaging. You can love somebody, remember good times with them and recognise the ways they've hurt you without any of those things cancelling each other out.
But sometimes, what you're grieving isn't even the relationship as it existed.
It's the relationship you thought you might eventually have.
The one you kept hoping would emerge if you were patient enough, understanding enough, successful enough, forgiving enough or simply good enough.
Perhaps you spent years trying to be the sort of person they would finally be proud of. Perhaps you convinced yourself that if you could just explain things a little better, achieve something significant, make the right decisions or stop upsetting them, then you might finally receive the love and approval you had been looking for.
And perhaps, eventually, you began to realise that the goalposts were never going to stop moving.
That no amount of achievement could guarantee approval. That no amount of patience could make somebody willing to understand you. That no amount of love from your side could manufacture the same thing in return.
I think that's a particularly uncomfortable thing to come to terms with, because it means acknowledging that something you've spent so much of your life wanting might never have been within your control to begin with.
And even when you understand that, some small, deeply ingrained part of you might still be waiting.
Waiting for the phone call. The apology. The acknowledgement. The moment when somebody finally says, “I understand now. I'm sorry. You deserved better.”
You can know that you're unlikely ever to hear those words and still wish, desperately, that you could.
You can build a life you're proud of and still wonder whether they would be proud of you, too.
And that's the bit that can make you feel as though you've somehow gone backwards. You thought you'd worked through it. You thought you'd accepted things for what they were. Then something happens, and you realise there's still a part of you that wants to be seen by them.
I don't think we should be too hard on ourselves for that.
These aren't usually feelings that appear overnight. They're often the product of years of trying to get something from somebody whose approval mattered to us long before we were old enough to understand the dynamics of the relationship.
Why would those feelings simply disappear because we've finally recognised that we cannot keep trying?
Perhaps the most painful part of family estrangement is that, even after you've accepted the reality of a relationship, you can still find yourself longing for the version of it that existed only in your hopes.
You can know that somebody will never give you the approval you spent years trying to earn, and still want them to be proud of you. You can know that they cannot be relied upon when life falls apart, and still instinctively want to call them when it does. You can recognise that you were right to walk away, and still wish that walking away had never been necessary.
Because sometimes, you aren't longing for the person who hurt you.
You're longing for the person you needed them to be.
And perhaps the cruellest part is that the more you come to terms with the fact that this person may never exist, the more clearly you understand exactly what you've been grieving all along.
You can know better and still want better:
One thing I've come to understand is that knowing something intellectually and accepting it emotionally are two very different things.
You can understand precisely why a relationship is unhealthy and still struggle with the loss of it. You can recognise that somebody is incapable of giving you what you need and still find yourself wanting them to give it to you.
You can understand that you aren't responsible for another person's behaviour and still wonder whether there was something you could have done differently.
You can know that you're not the problem and still find yourself questioning whether, somehow, you were.
It's frustrating, because there's a temptation to believe that once you've done enough work on yourself, you'll eventually reach a point where none of it bothers you anymore.
That you'll have established your boundaries, worked through your feelings and reached some enlightened state of acceptance in which you can think about the whole thing without experiencing even the slightest emotional wobble.
If that happens, lovely. Genuinely, good for you.
But I'm not convinced that healing necessarily looks like that for everyone.
Sometimes, you feel absolutely fine about the whole thing. Sometimes, you feel sad. Sometimes, you're angry about things that happened years ago, and sometimes, you can't quite understand why something that once caused you so much pain no longer seems to bother you at all.
And then, just when you think you've got your head around it, something happens and you're reminded that it's still there.
I don't necessarily think that means you've gone backwards. I think it means you're dealing with something that matters to you, something that has shaped your understanding of relationships, family and what it means to be loved.
We need to give ourselves a little more room to experience those feelings without immediately treating them as a problem that needs fixing.
You can miss somebody without contacting them. You can love somebody without allowing them access to you. You can feel sad about a relationship without deciding that you made the wrong choice in leaving it.
You can wish somebody were different without making it your responsibility to help them become that person.
There's a difference between acknowledging that you wish things had been different and continuing to live as though it's your job to make them different.
One is a feeling. The other can become a lifelong pursuit.
At some point, you have to allow yourself to stop pursuing something that has repeatedly shown you it isn't within your control.
That doesn't mean you stop caring. It means you stop making your own wellbeing dependent on the possibility that somebody else might eventually change.
So, where does that leave us?
I don't have a particularly inspirational conclusion to offer here. I haven't uncovered a magical solution to family estrangement, and I certainly don't think a blog post can adequately capture the complexity of every situation that leads somebody to make that decision.
Every family is different. Every relationship has its own history, its own nuances and its own reasons for reaching the point it does.
I'm not suggesting that estrangement is always permanent, that reconciliation is never possible, or that every difficult family relationship must inevitably end in distance. Those decisions are deeply personal, and nobody outside a relationship can fully understand everything that has brought it to that point.
What I do think is important, though, is that we stop treating family estrangement as something that can be understood simply by looking at a family tree.
A relationship isn't automatically healthy because it's a familial one. And a person isn't automatically cruel for deciding that they can no longer maintain it.
Sometimes, distance is the last resort after years of trying to make something work. Sometimes, it's the first opportunity somebody has had to prioritise their own wellbeing.
And sometimes, even after making that decision, they still grieve.
They grieve the birthdays, the celebrations, the difficult days and the ordinary little moments they cannot share. They grieve the support they cannot rely on, the conversations they cannot have and the milestones they might never get to celebrate together.
But they also grieve the relationship they thought they would have. The support they assumed would be there. The approval they spent years trying to earn. The idea that, when life became difficult, they would always have certain people to turn to.
I think that's the part of estrangement that is hardest to explain to people who haven't experienced it.
You can make a decision that is absolutely necessary for your own wellbeing and still wish, with every fibre of your being, that you had never needed to make it.
You can be relieved to be free of a relationship and devastated by what its absence represents.
You can spend years learning not to reach for somebody, only to discover that, in your most vulnerable moments, the instinct to do so hasn't entirely disappeared.
I don't believe the answer is to convince ourselves that we never needed those people, or that their absence shouldn't hurt because we've chosen to create it.
We did need them. Or, at the very least, we needed what they were supposed to provide. And I don't think there's anything shameful about acknowledging that.
The fact that we couldn't get those things from the people we needed them from doesn't mean we were wrong to want them. It doesn't mean we were too difficult to love or somehow undeserving of the support we were looking for.
It means that something we needed wasn't there, and that we've had to find a way to live with that.
Perhaps the hardest part is accepting that the person we long for in those difficult moments might never have existed outside our own hopes and expectations.
That the comfort we crave, the reassurance we want and the approval we still seek are attached, at least in part, to an idea of somebody rather than the lived experience of being loved by them in the way we needed.
It's a painful realisation, because it means letting go of more than a person. It means letting go of a possibility. Of the hope that one day, everything might finally fall into place and we might receive the love we've spent so long trying to earn.
But there's something important in recognising that, too.
If somebody's approval was never something you could guarantee through your own behaviour, then its absence was never proof that you weren't worthy of it.
You don't have to keep proving yourself to somebody in the hope that they'll eventually see your worth. You don't have to keep reopening old wounds in the hope that the person responsible for them will be the one to heal them. And you don't have to return to a relationship that hurt you simply because you still wish it could have been different.
You're allowed to stop waiting.
You're allowed to build a life that feels safe, happy and fulfilling, even if the people you once imagined sharing it with are not part of it.
I think, for me, that's what moving forward ultimately comes down to. Not reaching a point where I no longer wish things had been different, but recognising that I cannot build my future around the hope that somebody else will eventually become the person I needed them to be.
I can still have difficult days. I can still wish I could pick up the phone. I can still feel that familiar pang when something happens that I would once have wanted to share with them.
But I can also learn to reach for the people who are there. The ones who show up, who listen, who offer support without making me feel that I have to earn it, and who love me without making that love feel conditional.
I can build relationships in which I don't have to constantly question whether I'm worthy of being cared for.
And I can accept that, although it isn't the family dynamic I would have chosen for myself, the life I build instead can still be meaningful.
I don't think we need to pretend these relationships didn't matter to us. We don't need to rewrite our histories, dismiss the good memories or convince ourselves that we never wanted those people in our lives.
We can acknowledge that we wanted them there. That we still wish, sometimes, that things had been different.
But we can also acknowledge that wanting something and being able to have it are two very different things.
Because perhaps the most difficult part of family estrangement isn't accepting that somebody cannot give you what you need.
Perhaps it's accepting that, even after everything, you might never stop wishing they could.
And learning that you can live with that feeling without allowing it to decide what happens next.
Even if, every now and then, you still wish you could pick up the phone.